Incaroo

LLC vs Corporation vs S‑Corporation

Choosing an entity shouldn’t be confusing. This practical guide compares liability, taxes, ownership, payroll, investors, and compliance—so you can pick the right structure with confidence.

LLC

Flexible, simple, pass‑through by default. Best for most small businesses and partnerships.

C‑Corp

Standard for startups raising venture capital or planning an IPO. Allows multiple share classes.

S‑Corp

A tax election (not an entity). Can reduce self‑employment tax if you pay yourself a reasonable salary and take distributions.


LLC

Limited liability protection for owners

Pass‑through taxation by default (no double tax)

Flexible management and ownership structure

Light formalities (no board or annual meetings required in most states)

Self‑employment tax on all net profits (unless electing S‑Corp)

VCs often prefer corporations over LLCs

C‑Corporation

Preferred by venture capital and institutional investors

Multiple share classes and equity instruments (options, RSUs)

Clear corporate governance and legal precedent (esp. Delaware)

Double taxation (corporate tax + shareholder dividends)

More formalities: board, bylaws, annual meetings, minutes

S‑Corporation

Potential savings on self‑employment taxes

Pass‑through taxation (no corporate‑level tax)

Eligibility limits: ≤100 shareholders, all U.S. persons, one class of stock

Payroll required for owners (reasonable salary, payroll filings)


Side‑by‑Side Comparison

FactorLLCC‑CorpS‑Corp
Liability ProtectionYesYesYes (via LLC or Corp with S‑Election)
TaxationPass‑through (default)Corporate tax + dividendsPass‑through (salary + distributions)
Owner Payroll RequiredNoNo (unless employed)Yes (reasonable salary)
Investors / VC FriendlySometimesYes (esp. Delaware)Sometimes (with constraints)
Share ClassesN/A (units)Multiple classesOne class only
Admin ComplexityLowHighMedium (payroll + filings)

When an S‑Corp Election Makes Sense

An S‑Corp is a tax election for an LLC or corporation. It can reduce self‑employment taxes by paying the owner a reasonable salary (subject to payroll taxes) and taking remaining profits as distributions.

Eligibility: ≤100 shareholders, all U.S. persons, one class of stock; some entities and owners are excluded.


Simple Decision Framework

Ask yourself:
  • Will you raise venture capital or issue equity broadly? → Choose a Delaware C‑Corp.

  • Are you a small business/solo with profits after paying yourself? → LLC with S‑Corp election may help.

  • Do you want maximum flexibility and simplicity? → LLC.

Result for most founders: Start with an LLC
This guide provides general information and should not be considered legal or tax advice. Consult professionals for your situation.